Nutella Cream Pie

Nutella Cream Pie

I have told you about our Thai exchange student, Yong, before.     She came to live with my family when I was in high school and her family would send us hot sauce every now and then.  By the time she left I completely craved that hot peppery mixture even though it left me downing glasses of water.  At the time I couldn’t find it in our supermarket and when I finally could (Yay, Wegmans!!) I was so happy.

I haven’t mentioned that we also had an exchange student from Switzerland.  Gaby’s family would send us packages of the most wonderful chocolate that you have ever tasted.  I’m not sure what it is about Swiss chocolate, but it is nothing like the kind we have here in the US.  Sorry, Hershey, but its true.  When she left they would occasionally send us samples. When my father and I went to visit her family in Switzerland her mom filled my room with a bowl of chocolate every day.   Now that is hospitality!

Then several many years later, Nutella came mainstream to shelves in the US  and I was once again jumping up and down with exchange student inspired nostalgia.  Although Nutella is actually from an Italian company – the people who make the Ferrero Rocher chocolate balls – it was still that same wonderful taste of the Swiss chocolates I remembered.  I was so happy I could have chocolate and hazelnut whenever I wanted…..well sort of.

Very much like Biscoff, I can’t keep Nutella in my house without someone wanting a spoonful every hour on the hour.  So I really try not to have either in my cupboards very often ever.  However, when Ella asked if I would make a Nutella Pie I happily obliged.  I bought the smallest jar I could find so we wouldn’t have day after day of Nutella spoon requests.

This Nutella Cream Pie is wonderful.  Dreamy really.  With that being said, I didn’t think it tasted as Nutella-ey as I hoped it would.  Don’t get my wrong, it still tasted like a chocolate cream pie with fresh whipped cream (and what could possibly be wrong with that), but the Nutella flavor was not as prevalent as I had hoped.  So when I make this again (and I will) I will add another half cup of Nutella to the filling.  I think Lauren even suggested doing this in her original post.  Either way, this is an absolutely wonderful treat!

We debated making it with a graham cracker or pastry crust and Taylor wanted pastry so that is what we went with (Not to mention I already had one in the freezer.)  Jim said it tasted like a pie you would get at a diner and I would say that was a big compliment.  So thumbs up all around my house for this Nutella Cream Pie.


Source:  Lauren’s Latest

Nutella Cream Pie
  • 1-9 inch pie shell - baked prior to filling
  • 2 cups whole milk
  • ¼ cup unsweetened cocoa, sifted
  • ½ cup granulated sugar
  • ¼ cup cornstarch
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • ½ cup Nutella (If you want more Nutella flavor you can add an additional ½ cup)
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • ¼ cup granulated sugar
  • ½ tablespoon corn starch
  • ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
  1. Off the stove combine the cocoa, sugar and cornstarch. Slowly add the cold milk to the dry ingredients and whisk continually over medium heat on the stovetop. When the pudding starts to bubble it will eventually thicken. Take off the heat and add the vanilla and Nutella. Whisk everything until smooth. Pour into cooled pie shell and place plastic wrap right on top of the filling. Refrigerate at least two hours or until the pudding is set.
  2. For the whipped cream place the heavy cream, sugar, cornstarch and vanilla in the bowl of your mixer. Whip the cream until peaks form. Spread whipped cream over pie filling and serve. Enjoy!



  1. It looks tasty!

  2. Barbara Schieving says:

    What a fun way to change up chocolate cream pie. I’m a Nutella lover too.

  3. cream pies are so versatile and they’re nearly always delightfully decadent and delicious. this one is certainly no exception and i can already tell you it’ll be near the top of my list of favorites!

  4. Oh Nutella Cream Pie how I love you! One of the dreamiest pies I ever set eyes on!

Speak Your Mind


Rate this recipe: